What to Do When Middle Management Resists a Change Initiative?

Lander Van Belle ·
Manager zit alleen aan het hoofd van een boardroomtafel, armen over een gesloten map, met regenachtig Brussel achter het raam

Want to stay up to date with our latest insights and job openings? Subscribe to our newsletter.

When middle management works against a change initiative, you first find out why they are resisting, discuss it openly, and give them an active role in the approach. If the resistance persists, you choose between intensive coaching, a reshuffling of roles, or a replacement. Looking for new managers or temporary reinforcement? Take a look at our talent pool.

Resistance is usually a signal, not a character trait. Middle managers stand between the executive team and the shop floor, and they feel every change there first. Below, we look at where the resistance comes from, how to recognize it, and which steps work.

Why does middle management often work against change?

Middle managers often work against change because they have the most to lose from it: influence, status, security, or control over their team. They have to carry out the change without having helped shape it. That understandably triggers resistance to change.

A number of causes come up again and again in change initiatives:

  • Loss of role or position: a new structure can reduce their responsibilities or decision-making room.
  • Lack of involvement: they hear about the plans after the decisions have already been made.
  • Double pressure: they have to deliver daily results and drive the change initiative at the same time.
  • Unclear vision: if they don’t understand the why, they can’t explain it to their team either.
  • Earlier failed initiatives: those who have already seen several initiatives fail are less quick to believe in the next one.

Much of this resistance therefore stems from the way the initiative was set up, not from unwillingness.

How do you recognize that middle managers are sabotaging a change?

You recognize sabotage by behavior that appears to cooperate openly but in practice slows down or undermines the change. Think of postponed actions, selective communication to the team, and constant criticism of details. Such signals are often subtle and only stand out when you put them side by side.

Watch for these concrete signals:

  • Agreements and deadlines from the change initiative are structurally pushed back.
  • Employees receive a different or vaguer message than the executive team intended.
  • A manager says yes in the meeting but does nothing with the agreements afterwards.
  • Problems are blown out of proportion, while successes go undiscussed.
  • Informal coalitions emerge that question the new approach.

Distinguish between critical questions and genuine opposition. A manager who voices concerns and thinks along helps you improve. A manager who deliberately holds things back calls for a different approach.

What can the executive team do to bring middle managers on board?

The executive team brings middle managers on board by involving them early, explaining the reason for the change clearly, and giving them real decision-making room. Those who get to help build the approach feel ownership of the result instead of being the executor of someone else’s plan.

This works in practice:

  1. Involve them before the decision. Ask middle managers for input during the design phase, so they can flag practical obstacles in advance.
  2. Explain the why. Give them enough context to answer their team’s questions themselves.
  3. Make their new role concrete. Tell them what changes for them, even if that is uncomfortable.
  4. Give time and support. Make room in their schedules and offer training or coaching.
  5. Acknowledge their contribution. Visibly recognize what they set in motion.

Good leadership during change means the executive team listens, not just broadcasts. Involving middle managers in change also gives you valuable information about what is really going on on the shop floor.

How do you have a difficult conversation with a resisting manager?

You have that conversation by naming concrete behavior, describing the impact, and then sincerely asking about the reason behind it. Keep it factual, private, and focused on reaching an agreement. This gives you insight into the real cause of the resistance.

A useful structure:

  • Start with facts: describe what you saw, such as missed deadlines or contradictory messages, without interpretation.
  • Name the impact: explain what this does to the team and the initiative.
  • Dig deeper: “What is holding you back?” often brings out more than an accusation.
  • Really listen: sometimes there turns out to be a legitimate substantive objection.
  • Make agreements: record what you expect from each other and when you will review progress.

Avoid accusations and public confrontations. A manager who feels cornered is more likely to disengage for good.

When is it better to replace a manager?

Replacing is better when a manager keeps resisting after clear feedback, support, and sufficient time, and the initiative is structurally suffering as a result. It is not a first step but a last one: you weigh the cost of a departure against the cost of a lasting blockage.

First ask yourself these questions:

  • Has the expectation been made explicit and put in writing?
  • Was the manager offered coaching, training, or an adjusted role?
  • Has there been no visible improvement over several months?
  • Does the behavior also affect other team members and their motivation?
  • Does the manager still fit the direction the organization is choosing?

A manager can perform excellently in the old situation and still not fit the new one. That is not a personal failing. It is, however, a signal to prepare a careful, respectful transition.

When can an interim manager make the difference?

An interim manager makes the difference when you need experienced leadership quickly to make a change initiative succeed, without immediately making a permanent decision. They bring distance, experience, and speed, and can get a blocked department moving again.

An interim manager is especially useful in these situations:

  • A manager leaves or is replaced and the initiative cannot be allowed to stall.
  • You need neutral experience to break through resistance without internal politics.
  • The organization lacks the capacity to carry both the initiative and the day-to-day operations at the same time.
  • You want to stabilize first and only then, in peace, look for the right permanent successor.

This way you can opt for an interim manager for your change initiative while also taking the time to properly prepare the permanent solution.

How Skill&Will helps with resistance in middle management

We help you in three ways to get a stalled change initiative moving again. We know the Belgian market, and especially Brussels and Flemish Brabant, and we look for profiles that truly fit your situation and culture.

  • Interim management: experienced professionals who step in quickly to stabilize a department and drive the initiative.
  • Permanent recruitment at mid and senior level: a carefully selected shortlist of managers who fit your new direction.
  • Executive search: discreet searches for leaders who can carry change.

No pile of résumés, but a targeted selection with insight into every profile. Want to discuss which approach fits your situation? Get in touch with us and we’ll gladly think along with you.

Related Articles

Cookies & Privacy

We use cookies to improve your experience.